Five exits in five weeks, one thesis: luxury keeps changing the face on the label and hoping the numbers will follow.
On November 5, Balenciaga announced that Pierpaolo Piccioli was leaving after just 16 months. The next day, Kering named his successor, Martine Rose, due to start on November 16. Five days after that, the house opened a global celebration of the Le City bag, an accessory that has survived every creative director who has touched it since 2001. Read those three dates together and they make the argument of this piece: the thing that lasts is almost never the person we spend so much energy replacing.
The reshuffle is hard to follow because it moves so fast. Anthony Vaccarello left Saint Laurent after ten years, announced on October 9. Seán McGirr left McQueen after three. Veronica Leoni left Calvin Klein after four seasons, having returned the house to New York Fashion Week as the first woman to lead it. Glenn Martens is stepping away from Diesel after its Spring/Summer 2027 show and stays at Margiela. This all comes as the dust had barely settled on a round of appointments at Chanel, Gucci and Bottega Veneta. In the meantime, Saint Laurent says it will soon announce new leadership, with Chloé’s Chemena Kamali widely tipped as the successor.
The exits are not one story
It is tempting to read this as a verdict on talent. It isn’t. McGirr’s contract had simply expired, and Puck’s reading of the moment is that the exits reflect a pivot from luxury ambition to pragmatic portfolio management, with Kering CEO Luca de Meo taking an unsparing approach to right-sizing a group in which almost every brand is underperforming.
Vaccarello is the most telling case. Saint Laurent credits him with a period of major commercial growth and the house continued to return to growth in the latest quarter on demand in North America and Western Europe. A designer who leaves while the numbers are rising is not being corrected but he is being reallocated. Dario Vitale, appointed Versace’s chief creative officer in April 2025, was dismissed in December by Prada Group shortly after it bought the house in a $1.4bn deal. New owners redraw the map and designers are the most visible lines on it.
At Balenciaga, WWD reported that Piccioli left after mixed reviews of his collections and that Kering is understood to want a return to the edgier, less romantic direction of the Demna years. Seen that way, it is a change of taste at the top not a verdict on craft. Whether it will fix anything is a different question.
The real problem is on the balance sheet
Here is what a designer cannot change by himself. The personal luxury goods market fell to €358 billion in 2025 from €364 billion the year before, and Bain and Altagamma expect growth of only 2% to 4% this year. The number of people who buy luxury goods has reportedly fallen from about 400 million in 2022 to around 330 million. A like-for-like iconic handbag cost 50% to 70% more in 2025 than in 2019. Leather goods and shoes, the engines of luxury profit, softened under price fatigue, and Bain’s Claudia D’Arpizio said consumers still want to buy but are waiting for brands to price correctly and for the value proposition to normalize.
Then there is how people spend. Demand for experiences is growing roughly 1.5 times faster than demand for tangible goods and about half of luxury shoppers now consult the secondhand market before buying new. Consumers still have the appetite, according to Bain but far less tolerance for disappointing products or experiences.
Kering’s own numbers show how much of the fix sits outside the studio. Its third-quarter revenue was down 1% on a comparable basis, with fashion and leather goods down 3%, while jewelry and eyewear grew. Gucci fell 9% in the first half of the year. Its ReconKering plan reads like a logistics brief, not an art direction one: cut Gucci’s selling space by 20% and its outlets by a third, and restore pricing power lost during the over-distribution years. The group plans at least 125 net store closures this year. No collection, however good, can un-saturate a store network.
Why the swap doesn’t solve it
The first reason is cost. Strategist Christopher Morency argues that newness through a new creative director is seen as a fix-all, but that it disrupts store designs, teams and cost structures, and that CEOs should ask what proof there is that it still works. The second is time. A 16-month tenure delivered Piccioli three ready-to-wear collections. A brand’s story, the one a customer actually buys into, takes longer than that to tell and every reset starts the clock again.
The third reason is what holds a brand up. Analyst Luca Solca has long argued that the most likely model of success is a strong creative director paired with a strong CEO, with Gucci under Alessandro Michele and Marco Bizzarri as the case study, and that designers need time and space to deliver. Hermès is the standing counterexample to constant change: its lasting success suggests that consistency is what customers value. That does not mean a new designer can never help. Michele’s arrival really did shock Gucci back into growth. But that story worked because of the partnership and the patience around him, which is exactly what a fast rotation removes.
There is also a structural twist. Kering’s operating model moves industrial production and client management into shared hubs above the brands, so that brands can focus on creativity and product. In theory that frees the designer. In practice, as Puck noted of Kamali’s likely move, it can mean a smaller sphere of influence and more pressure.
What the carousel misses
If the argument stopped at “stop firing people”, it would be a complaint. Here is the more useful version. Customers, and Gen Z most of all, increasingly follow objects, moods and stories, and they check the resale market before they commit. They want to know where a piece came from and who carried it, which is why a bag with almost no branding is being celebrated at 25 as a community and a lineage. Every Balenciaga creative director since Ghesquière has done something with the Le City, and the bag has outlasted all of them. The lesson is that heritage lives in the thing that was made, not in the name of its latest author.
That points to what would actually help: pricing that makes sense at the entry point, distribution that restores desire, product people don’t regret buying, and creative leaders with a seat in all of those conversations. Creative and commercial decisions are one conversation, and the designer is only the part of it that gets photographed.
The last word
Luxury is a business of long memories. Its most valuable asset is a customer’s belief that a house will still mean something in ten years. Every swap, however well-intentioned, asks that customer to start believing again from the beginning. The industry will keep changing its faces for as long as faces are easier to change than systems. Until it learns the difference, the carousel will keep turning, and the problem will keep getting a new coat.
